Now the question is whether this collective unconsciousness is a long train of society working or true biological memory, a la assassin's creed. My answer is I don't know. It does not matter. But I will guess the answer.
I think it is more of society teaching then instinct. But one cannot deny instinct does exist. As such, the question is whether instinct or teaching. Are we born a blank slate and then taught or are we who we are as we are born initially? I believe some people are born with instinct and some people are born with learning. And then there are those who are born with both. Both survive and live equally, but there are many tells as to who is who. Those that learn fit their mold imperfectly. Those that have instinct fit their mold perfectly.
Those that have instinct will enjoy enjoy what those who learn create because all things fit the magical formula that is instinct. One cannot ignore in the formula. Those who are strongest in instinct will react violently. Those who are weaker will be more submissive until they learn not to be. There is an unless. If your instinct is to be submissive, then you will be submissive. If your instinct is to be dominant, then you will be more dominant. One could argue that those who learn's instinct is to learn.
Nice Ni rant there in the essay. Look, I'm doing it too!
Now the question is whether this collective unconsciousness is a long train of society working or true biological memory, a la assassin's creed. My answer is I don't know. It does not matter. But I will guess the answer.
I think it is more of society teaching then instinct. But one cannot deny instinct does exist. As such, the question is whether instinct or teaching. Are we born a blank slate and then taught or are we who we are as we are born initially? I believe some people are born with instinct and some people are born with learning. And then there are those who are born with both. Both survive and live equally, but there are many tells as to who is who. Those that learn fit their mold imperfectly. Those that have instinct fit their mold perfectly.
Those that have instinct will enjoy enjoy what those who learn create because all things fit the magical formula that is instinct. One cannot ignore in the formula. Those who are strongest in instinct will react violently. Those who are weaker will be more submissive until they learn not to be. There is an unless. If your instinct is to be submissive, then you will be submissive. If your instinct is to be dominant, then you will be more dominant. One could argue that those who learn's instinct is to learn.
Nice Ni rant there in the essay. Look, I'm doing it too!
This reminds me why functions are almost as bad as astrology
I read the archtype descriptions and assigned what functions would fit that description for me.
I tried being objective doing this, but I think some of them were incredibly suggestive.
These are my results:
Hero: Save the day
Ni, Ne, Si, Te
Parent: taking care of others
Te, Fe, Ti
Child: creativity
Ne
Animus: purpose, inspiration, ideal
Fe, Ti, Si
Opposing: adversarial, passive-aggressive, suspicious, avoidant, defence
Ne
Senex: finds fault with everyone
Ni, Si, Ti, Fi
Trickster: ambiguous, fooling and confusing others
Ni, Ne
Demon: creativity, unconscious, source of evil
Ni, Fi
---------------------------------------------
I tried fitting Se somewhere, but it doesn't really apply to anything.
I analysed per type how many correct functions I have. I used 1 for matching. 0 for not matching.
INTJ: 1100 1100
INFJ: 1100 1100
ISTJ: 1100 0101
ISFJ: 1100 0101
INTP: 0001 0101
INFP: 0000 0100
ISTP: 0001 0110
ISFP: 0000 0110
ENTJ: 1000 0000
ENFJ: 0001 0000
ESTJ: 1010 0010
ESFJ: 0011 0010
ENTP: 1101 0000
ENFP: 1001 0000
ESTP: 0100 0000
ESFP: 0000 0000
IxxJ scores best. IxTP or ESxJ also. If I only look at the conscious functions, ENTP is best.
Oh man, another "INTJ". Why do we mistype as them so often?
The Se problem is a confusion with the function of Si. Se is the research function. Si is the touch function.
Socionics INTj is Bach. Funny thing. They only want us for their sick Ni games.