Typing: Houses | Page 4 | INFJ Forum

Typing: Houses

I watched every Harry Potter movie as it was well created. However to this day I do not see the allure of the story in general. I suppose the one part I was drawn to was the time Harry was laying on the floor after his uncle died and in a very bad place. The wizard guy said something profound to him at the time. I thought it to be very insightfull well past the overall story in general.
 
Whoever is a houseist, should look at this before judging. I think I have been cured, being shown that every house has its own aesthetic beauty.

f9cdea14ff576a9c7a8c6a7b9bcb6c15.jpg
Clearly Slytherin still looks the best. :p
 
I watched every Harry Potter movie as it was well created. However to this day I do not see the allure of the story in general. I suppose the one part I was drawn to was the time Harry was laying on the floor after his uncle died and in a very bad place. The wizard guy said something profound to him at the time. I thought it to be very insightfull well past the overall story in general.

The story was very alluring for me when watching especially the first two or three movies but it wasn't clear why at the time. Just that I really liked Harry's character and his life's journey over all - and that there was a strange sense of purposefulness to the events in his life as portrayed by the different movies.

Anyway apparently HP is a creative spin on the solar hero myth; adding a small excerpt on it from one of my books, but don't want to get in trouble by including any more.

As a child the hero has no idea of his true parentage. He thinks he
is just like everybody else, but he has a nagging feeling of being
different and an intuition of a special destiny. One of the main themes
of the hero's quest is the discovery of his true origin, which is both
mortal and immortal. In this mythic image of hybrid birth we can
perceive a deep sense of duality, a conviction that we are not merely
made of earth and doomed to eat, reproduce and die. Each of us is
special, unique, and has a personal destiny, an individual
contribution to make to life. [...]

Another important element in the solar hero's childhood is that he
is usually envied or persecuted without knowing why. Sometimes the
enemy is his mother's husband, who is really his stepfather.
Sometimes it is a usurping or wicked king who has had an omen or
augury and fears that the hero, having reached manhood, will
overthrow him. We can see this theme in the stories of Greek heroes
such as Perseus as well as in the story of Jesus, who as an infant was
persecuted by King Herod. The theme of envy, and the potential
threat the hero holds for the ruling powers, is one which I
will refer to many times as we explore the solar journey. The Sun is special, and
the expression of specialness often invokes destructive envy in others. [...]

At some point in his growing-up process, the hero receives what
Campbell refers to as "the call to adventure." This can come in a
number of forms. The divine parent may appear in a dream or vision,
saying, "All right, son, pull your finger out, it's time to grow up and go
after the treasure hard to attain." In other words, the call may come
from within us a sudden intuition of meaning and destiny...

(the book referenced here is The Hero with a Thousand Faces which I haven't read but need to at some point.)
 
Harry Potter is such a dark story. Darker than many in real life. I suppose this is an aspect that elludes my understanding. Much like Lemony Snicket or whatever its called.
If anyone has time to explain why they like it, Id like to hear.
Thank you @jkxx for doing this already.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Free and jkxx
Harry Potter is such a dark story. Darker than many in real life. I suppose this is an aspect that elludes my understanding. Much like Lemony Snicket or whatever its called.
If anyone has time to explain why they like it, Id like to hear.
Thank you @jkxx for doing this already.
Perhaps it appeals to some dark part of people's personality?
 
There are a myriad of reasons why it is appealing. But in accordance with the dark and light dichotomy, the books and movies speak of the inherent darkness even in people who are mostly light. The story describes allegorically that what matters is the choices we make (whether we seem to be mostly light or dark), they teach acceptance and welcoming of diversity (at least statistically), and not to give up in the face of adversity.

There are some quotes to be found on the internet which address this very thing.
 
Harry Potter is such a dark story. Darker than many in real life. I suppose this is an aspect that elludes my understanding.
This is a surprising perspective. I have found the HP series to be among the most light within the genre. But then again, you only reference real life stories, which is not exactly commensurable.

One of the Dumbledore quotes may apply here:
il_570xN.540467286_eooh.jpg
 
I watched every Harry Potter movie as it was well created. However to this day I do not see the allure of the story in general. I suppose the one part I was drawn to was the time Harry was laying on the floor after his uncle died and in a very bad place. The wizard guy said something profound to him at the time. I thought it to be very insightfull well past the overall story in general.
I can see how someone who has only seen the movies could be left wondering about all the hype. I personally think the movies are good but they don't do the story justice, as is usually the case when something is condensed for the big screen. In feel like if I were to start telling you about all the aspects of the story that draw me in you'd be wondering where I came up with this or that and I'd have to point out that it's in the books.

Anyway, you mention Harry's uncle dying... Maybe you mean his godfather Sirius? And what profound thing was it that you connected with?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Free and Ginny
I can see how someone who has only seen the movies could be left wondering about all the hype. I personally think the movies are good but they don't do the story justice, as is usually the case when something is condensed for the big screen. In feel like if I were to start telling you about all the aspects of the story that draw me in you'd be wondering where I came up with this or that and I'd have to point out that it's in the books.

Anyway, you mention Harry's uncle dying... Maybe you mean his godfather Sirius? And what profound thing was it that you connected with?
Sirius... the most needless death in the series. Besides three of the deaths at the Hogwarts Battle. And by that I mean that I didn't want them to happen. They probably had their reasons for being, but these people were the ones I liked the most. The bereaved shouldn't have had to suffer their absence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Free and Wildfire
Who else was disappointed that they never got a Hogwarts letter? I guess I'll have to content myself living the filthy muggle life. *le sigh*
 
Who else was disappointed that they never got a Hogwarts letter? I guess I'll have to content myself living the filthy muggle life. *le sigh*
*raises hand*
I once worked out this entire Harry Potter RPG videogame idea based on the 5th year where you got to join the inquisition squad or the DA to spy on the other.
 
*raises hand*
I once worked out this entire Harry Potter RPG videogame idea based on the 5th year where you got to join the inquisition squad or the DA to spy on the other.

The only reason that I'd join DA was so I could turn Umbridge into a rat and feed it to Nagini.