https://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=127760520596863
In this relatively recent video Claudio Naranjo claims that he invented the enneagram out of thin air using automatic writing to fill in some words used by Ichazo.
He is surprised at how the system took off, and says that it has little or no merit.
The MBTI is weird enough in its origins. The enneagram is just plain weird. People now speak with great authority about it, and there are probably fifty books, some of which are best sellers. I find it intriguing that Naranjo himself wrote a book entitled Character and Neurosis in which he says the INFJ and the INFP are fours (he makes many links between the enneagram and the MBTI system).
But he seems to have just been playing around. It's fun to look at the video and reflect on the validity of the enneagram.
Personally I think the MBTI is more sound. It has better and sounder descriptions and has better research.
In this relatively recent video Claudio Naranjo claims that he invented the enneagram out of thin air using automatic writing to fill in some words used by Ichazo.
He is surprised at how the system took off, and says that it has little or no merit.
The MBTI is weird enough in its origins. The enneagram is just plain weird. People now speak with great authority about it, and there are probably fifty books, some of which are best sellers. I find it intriguing that Naranjo himself wrote a book entitled Character and Neurosis in which he says the INFJ and the INFP are fours (he makes many links between the enneagram and the MBTI system).
But he seems to have just been playing around. It's fun to look at the video and reflect on the validity of the enneagram.
Personally I think the MBTI is more sound. It has better and sounder descriptions and has better research.